S&P 500 Falls Below 200-Day Moving Average, Historical Data Suggests Long-Term Holders Need Not Panic

技术指标与情绪双双“爆表”,华尔街专家拉响美股回调警报
Published on: Nov 18, 2026
Author: Amy Liu

The S&P 500 closed at 7,340.53 on Tuesday, November 17, slightly below its 200-day moving average of nearly 7,345. This marked the first time the index has closed below that line since April 7. Previously, the S&P 500 had stayed above the moving average for 155 consecutive trading days and set a record close of 7,818.93 on October 6. Since that high, the worst day was November 5, when a selloff in chipmakers and other artificial intelligence (AI)-related stocks pushed the index down more than 4%. As of this writing, the index is about 6% below its record high but still roughly 7% above its 2025 closing level.

Most Breaches Are Short-Lived

Based on daily closing data from Yahoo Finance since January 1950 (covering price changes only, excluding dividends), the analysis averaged the most recent 200 daily closes and counted the number of consecutive trading days the index remained above that average. The study identified 34 instances in which the index fell below its 200-day moving average after spending at least 150 consecutive trading days above it. The longest such streak was 628 trading days, which ended in May 1956. Notably, four of the most recent six breaches occurred in the 2020s, on February 27, 2020; January 21, 2022; March 10, 2025; and March 19 of this year. After the breach in March of this year, the index fell about another 4% over the next seven trading days, closed back above the moving average on April 8, and had risen about 14% by mid-June. In half of the 34 cases, the index closed back above its 200-day moving average within five trading days, and in 28 cases it recovered within 20 trading days (about four weeks). The 1987 breach was the biggest exception, as the index took 161 trading days to close back above the moving average.

Across all 34 breaches, the index rose over the following three months 76% of the time, with a median gain of about 4%. By comparison, for any randomly selected trading day since 1950, the three-month period starting on that day showed a gain about two-thirds of the time (67%), with a median gain of nearly 3%.

Should Long-Term Holders Sell?

Performance in the year after a breach looked more like an ordinary year. In the 33 breaches for which at least one year has passed, the index rose over the next 12 months in 23 cases, or about 70%, with a median gain of about 9%. Since 1950, a normal 12-month period has shown a gain about 75% of the time, with a median gain of about 11%. Of course, a breach does not always mean a calm year. In 11 of the 33 cases, the index at some point within 12 months fell 10% or more from its closing level on the day of the breach. This includes August 2007, when the index was down about 13% a year later. It also includes February 2020 and March 2025. In both of those cases, the index fell further within weeks, dropping about 25% through March 23, 2020, and about 11% through April 8, 2025. Yet in both cases the index ended the following 12 months higher, gaining about 28% and 21%, respectively.

For long-term holders of funds that track the S&P 500, historical data do not support selling after a breach of the 200-day moving average. In most cases, selling would mean missing the gains that followed in the ensuing months. Moreover, on the day of each breach, the cases that later developed into deeper declines did not look significantly different from the rest—on a median basis, the index was about 8% below its prior-year high in the former and about 7% below in the latter. Although the index could fall further from current levels, staying invested for the long term remains the more reasonable choice.

Dividend Yielding Stocks Financial Service Funds Futures Personal Finance