Pinnacle Silver & Gold Corp (TSXV: PINN)
Building a New Americas-Focused Silver and Gold Company
Gold prices advanced in early U.S. trading Wednesday, lifted by retreating crude oil prices and a slight easing of Treasury yield pressure, as markets counted down to a widely anticipated Federal Reserve interest rate decision. Spot gold traded at $4,342.50 per ounce, up 1.16% on the session, while spot silver rose 1.62% to $64.58 per ounce. Though a rate increase is broadly expected, historical data indicates gold investors have little cause to panic over a single hike.
Markets have priced in a 90% to 93% chance of a 25-basis-point rate rise, which would mark the Fed’s first hike since July 2023. Yet the effect of such a move has largely been absorbed by the market. What will ultimately determine gold’s next move is not the decision itself, but the forward-looking signals the central bank delivers on its policy path. A “one-and-done” message would relieve upward pressure on real yields, supporting precious metals. By contrast, if the Fed hints at further tightening ahead, the 10-year Treasury yield could hold near 5%, limiting upside for non-interest-bearing metals.
Conventional financial theory frames rate hikes as a clear negative for gold. Since bullion generates no yield, higher interest rates raise the opportunity cost of holding it relative to income-producing assets. But an analysis of 10 Fed hiking cycles dating to 1972 shows gold’s performance does not always align with this textbook logic.
In the month immediately following the first rate increase, gold typically faces short-term pressure, with an average decline of 0.7% and positive returns in just 4 of the 10 cycles. That weakness seldom persists, however. Three months after the initial hike, gold’s average return rebounds to 5%, with gains recorded in 7 cycles. At the six-month mark, the average advance reaches 6.6%. Over a full 12 months, gold posts an average gain of 6.1% and a median increase of 8.1%, finishing higher in 7 out of the 10 hiking cycles.
Performance has varied sharply across cycles. Gold rallied more than 27% in the year after each of the two tightening cycles launched in the 1970s. The steepest drop occurred during the aggressive Volcker era, which delivered the worst result in the sample — creating a nearly 74-percentage-point gap between the best and worst 12-month outcomes. Even the aggressive 2022 hiking cycle left gold 2.4% higher one year after its first rate increase.
The key to reconciling gold’s counterintuitive performance lies in the difference between nominal and real interest rates. Nominal rates are the stated yields on bonds, while real rates subtract inflation expectations to reflect the actual, inflation-adjusted return of holding fixed income instead of gold. When the Fed raises rates faster than inflation expectations cool, real yields climb and gold faces headwinds — the dynamic that drove the Volcker-era selloff. When inflation remains sticky, however, real rates can stay low even amid rate hikes, preserving gold’s appeal as an inflation hedge and store of value.
U.S. consumer prices climbed 3.4% year-over-year in August, and the federal funds rate currently sits in a range of 3.50% to 3.75%. A quarter-point hike would push the upper end of the range to 4%, leaving the policy rate roughly in line with inflation. This is a stark contrast to the Volcker years, when nominal rates were driven far above inflation, sending real yields surging — an environment that historically has been far more favorable for gold.
The Fed is due to release its policy statement and updated interest rate projections — the so-called dot plot — on Wednesday, followed by a press conference with the Fed chair. Markets will zero in on the dot plot for guidance on the trajectory of future rate moves. For gold investors, there is no need to overreact to a single rate decision. What will shape the medium- and long-term path of precious metals is the Fed’s forward policy signal and the resulting shift in real interest rates.
