Rare-Earth Prices Rise 23%, Yet Producers’ Stocks Fall 28%
Non-China NdPr has risen 23% year to date and now sits above the $110 per kilogram price floor, yet Canaccord’s covered rare-earth producers are down 28% on average and developers 17%, a clear disconnect between firming physical markets and falling equities.
The physical market is underpinned by price floors. The U.S. Department of Defense set an $110/kg NdPr floor for MP Materials, while Lynas and USA Rare Earth received comparable floor arrangements. Over the past 10 months, Chinese NdPr pricing has normalized toward the $110 level, easing the volatility that once made projects difficult to finance.
A wide gap has opened between East and West. Since China rationed heavy rare earths, the West has priced separately: dysprosium in Rotterdam trades near $1,074/kg against about $227 in China, while North American CIF samarium changes hands at 346 times the Chinese price. Japan has urgently appealed to the U.S. and global companies, warning of a severe yttrium shortage by year-end; Washington said it was receiving only two-thirds of the volume China pledged under last October’s truce, and last month’s summit produced only a two-month ceasefire. On demand, NdFeB magnet consumption is forecast to grow at a 7.3% compound annual rate to about 365,000 tonnes by 2035, with the global NdPr market in deficit through 2028 and roughly 7% short this year.
Stocks, meanwhile, have broadly sold off. The REMX ETF peaked in May and has since slid from above $100 to the high-$50s; Lynas, MP, USA Rare Earth and Iluka are all deeply lower. On valuation, producers trade at an average 0.57x P/NAV and developers at 0.47x; against bank targets, MP Materials offers 104% upside, Lynas 108% and USA Rare Earth 204%.
Canaccord attributes the gap to global macro rather than fundamentals: the 10-year Treasury yield sits above 5%, tech equities are wobbling and the speculative bid has faded, leaving long-duration, capital-intensive projects caught up in risk-off selling.
The same disconnect appears in tungsten, where China controls about 80% of supply. Western leader Almonty (ALM) has fallen below $9, down 62% from its April peak and beneath Goldman’s cautious $13 target. U.S. defense procurement rules extending to tungsten take effect January 1, 2027, when Chinese or Russian ore processed in a third country will no longer qualify.
Canaccord cautions the ex-China dysprosium-terbium market totaled just 151 tonnes in 2025 and questions whether current premiums are sustainable, but argues demand remains strong as the West seeks non-China supply; China’s dominance is unlikely to be shaken near term, it says, leaving bifurcated markets and premiums in place for years.
China News
Mining
Rare Earth
Tungsten