Pershing Square Capital Management’s latest quarterly holdings report shows that, as of September 30, the firm held 4,064,779 shares of Microsoft (MSFT), down about 2.1 million shares from 6,206,730 shares three months earlier—a reduction of roughly one-third. At first glance, this data appears to suggest that billionaire Bill Ackman has turned colder on Microsoft stock. However, Ackman himself says this interpretation is incorrect and that the logic behind it is actually entirely reasonable.
Ackman explained on X on Wednesday the transactions that were not reflected in the quarterly report. In July, Pershing Square bought 2 million “deep-in-the-money” Microsoft options with a strike price of about $310 per share and a term of two and a half years. These options were purchased through over-the-counter transactions and were therefore not included in the quarterly holdings report. “We remain bullish on Microsoft and believe the stock remains undervalued,” Ackman wrote.
The reason for swapping stock for options is that, after accounting for these options, Pershing Square’s bet on Microsoft is roughly the same size as before: about 4.1 million shares plus 2 million options, corresponding to the 6.2 million shares in June. Deep-in-the-money options behave very similarly to the underlying stock. Microsoft closed at $506.24 on Tuesday, and options with a $310 strike price move almost one-for-one with the share price, but their upfront cost is lower than buying the stock directly, thereby freeing up cash for other investments. Ackman said only that the firm occasionally carries out such swaps “for portfolio management or other reasons.” However, if Microsoft falls below $310 before the options expire, these options could become worthless, whereas holding the stock does not carry that risk.
Microsoft was not the only change. Pershing Square established a new position in Alcon (ALC) worth about $954 million and a position in Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) worth about $1 billion. The firm liquidated its remaining small stake in Hertz (HTZ). At the same time, Pershing Square reduced holdings in several major positions.
The lesson from this case is that investors should treat 13F holdings reports with caution. Such filings reflect only the stocks and listed options held at the end of each quarter and are released weeks later. Over-the-counter options transactions, short positions, and purchases or sales made afterward will not appear in the reports. Simply comparing reports across different quarters may produce headlines that a well-known investor “sold” a stock when in fact their investment conviction has not changed.
Looking at Pershing Square’s position adjustments this quarter as a whole, Ackman’s bet on Microsoft has not truly been reduced; rather, it has been structurally replaced through over-the-counter deep-in-the-money options, maintaining bullish exposure while freeing up capital flexibility. Long-term investors can still view this as a vote of confidence in Microsoft from one of Wall Street’s best-known stock pickers.