Low-Risk Precious Metals Investing: Royalty and Streaming Stocks

Low-Risk Precious Metals Investing: Royalty and Streaming Stocks
Published on: Feb 25, 2025

Many investors wish to gain exposure to precious metals but prefer to avoid the higher risk of directly operating or developing mines. In such cases, royalty and streaming stocks for gold and silver can be an attractive option: They offer a relatively low-risk investment that generates steady, predictable revenue and typically have portfolios spanning multiple mines and projects, thus providing significant diversification.

This article dives into how royalties and streaming work, their benefits, and some of the key royalty and streaming stocks and ETFs.

How Gold and Silver Royalties Work

Royalty companies usually provide funding in a mine’s early exploration or development phases; in return, they receive a share of the future revenue or royalties once the mine goes into production. These kinds of agreements date back hundreds of years to when miners paid “royalties” to the British Crown for the right to extract gold and silver from royal lands. Even today, many regions still require mining companies to share a portion of their revenue with the government in exchange for using public resources.

Example:

In 1986, Franco-Nevada (TSX:FNV, NYSE:FNV) paid US$2 million for a 4 percent royalty on Western States Minerals’ Goldstrike mine in Nevada, USA. Barrick Gold (TSX:ABX, NYSE:GOLD) later purchased Goldstrike and discovered a far larger resource, ultimately generating more than US$1 billion in royalties for Franco-Nevada. This deal became a landmark case in the royalty space.

How Gold and Silver Streaming Works

Streaming is similar to the royalty model; however, the return to the streaming company often comes in the form of actual metals (e.g. gold or silver) rather than cash payments. Under a streaming agreement, the streaming company pays an up-front investment in exchange for the right to purchase all or a portion of the produced metal at a fixed, below-market price. If production costs increase, the streaming company generally does not shoulder additional expenses; if metal prices drop, it can sometimes hold onto its metal until market conditions improve.

Example:

Franco-Nevada’s largest source of revenue comes from the gold and silver streaming agreement with Lundin Mining’s (TSX:LUN) Candelaria copper mine in Chile. In 2014, Franco-Nevada provided US$648 million in up-front financing to help Lundin acquire Freeport-McMoRan’s (NYSE:FCX) stake in the mine. In return, Franco-Nevada received a sizable portion of the mine’s gold and silver production, with the purchase price for those metals set significantly below spot prices.

Key Differences Between Royalties and Streaming:

Category Payment Structure Risk Applicable Resources Focus of Agreement
Royalties Cash (proportionate to mine revenue) Mining company bears price fluctuations Various minerals (including non-metals) A fee for the right to extract minerals
Streaming Physical metals (purchased at a fixed price) Streaming company can hold or sell the metals, bearing some price risk Primarily precious metals or widely traded commodities Long-term supply of metals at set terms

Why Invest in Royalty and Streaming Companies?

  • Lower Risk: These companies do not operate mines or handle day-to-day production activities. Consequently, they are less exposed to geopolitical or operational shocks such as labor disputes or sudden cost escalations. If one mine faces setbacks, royalties or streams on other mines in the portfolio may help offset losses.
  • Stable Revenue: Once a mine goes into production, royalties and streams offer a long-term, predictable revenue or metal supply. During weaker market conditions, some companies can store metals and wait for prices to recover, providing them added flexibility.
  • Growth Potential and Capital Risks: Large, established royalty companies often have strong cash flows and can fund new acquisitions internally. Younger companies may need external financing, leading to potential share dilution or increased debt—though they may offer higher growth potential if their deals succeed.

Major Gold/Silver Royalty and Streaming Companies

(The following have market caps exceeding C$1 billion or US$1 billion, as of February 19, 2025.)

  1. Wheaton Precious Metals (TSX:WPM, NYSE:WPM)
    Market Cap: ~C$44.46 billion
  2. Franco-Nevada (TSX:FNV, NYSE:FNV)
    Market Cap: ~C$38.23 billion
  3. Royal Gold (NASDAQ:RGLD)
    Market Cap: ~US$9.82 billion
  4. Osisko Gold Royalties (TSX:OR, NYSE:OR)
    Market Cap: ~C$5.1 billion
  5. Sandstorm Gold (TSX:SSL, NYSE:SAND)
    Market Cap: ~C$2.5 billion

Smaller-Cap Gold/Silver Royalty and Streaming Companies

(The following have market caps above C$10 million or US$10 million, as of February 19, 2025.)

  1. Metalla Royalty & Streaming (TSXV:MTA)
    Market Cap: ~C$408.08 million
  2. Gold Royalty (NYSEAMERICAN:GROY)
    Market Cap: ~US$242.12 million
  3. Sailfish Royalty (TSXV:FISH, OTCQX:SROYF)
    Market Cap: ~C$112.44 million
  4. Empress Royalty (TSXV:EMPR, OTCQX:EMPYF)
    Market Cap: ~C$41.96 million
  5. Silver Crown Royalties (NEO:SCRI, OTCQX:SLCRF)
    Market Cap: ~C$16.1 million

Precious Metals Royalty and Streaming ETFs

  • Betashares Global Royalties ETF (ASX:ROYL)
  • Betashares Global Gold Miners ETF (ASX:MNRS)
  • VanEck Gold Miners ETF (ARCA:GDX)

Conclusion

For investors who want exposure to gold or silver but do not want the direct risks of mining operations, royalty and streaming stocks are an attractive option. Large-cap companies with established portfolios provide comparatively stable and diversified holdings, while smaller-cap companies may offer greater growth potential with correspondingly higher risks.

Based on their own capital capacity and risk tolerance, investors can choose among major players, smaller up-and-coming firms, or ETFs to build a precious metals portfolio that meets their needs.

Financial Service Funds Gold Silver